by Son of a Beach » Mon 11 Apr, 2011 9:15 am
I always carry both. I generally don't need either, but I love looking at maps, and I always want to be prepared in case I decide to go off track, or do something different to originally planned (or indeed in case I lose my way).
I've only very recently started using a GPS for the first time (and being on my phone, its battery is unreliable). I've used the map and compass a few times. The first time was when we were doing the Reedy Lake track to Lees Paddocks the first time. The turn-off from the Arm River Track was almost invisible at that time, and we completely missed it. So we decided to go cross country and meet up with it. We navigated our way to Reedy Lake (being the most obvious nearby feature on the map near the track), and were relieved that our first attempt at off-track navigation worked well.
I've since used the map and compass several times deliberately to explore areas and navigate my way around a few trackless areas, just for fun and for practice. So it's mostly in areas with easy walking, and enough views to be able to navigate by. I quite enjoy doing this now.
Since getting a mapping GPS (on my phone) more recently, I now use a combination of both, but try to use the GPS only to confirm that I am indeed where I think I am. Most of the time I'm right, but occasionally I have found that I've misjudged location or direction. So it's good for me to keep practicing!