corvus wrote:tasadam.
How does the Nallo2 stack up against the "Snow Cave" for 4 season performance.
c
Yep, that my friend, is a brilliant question.
My honest take on it, given my limited experience with the Nallo2 -
The snowcave was heavy - literally twice the weight of the Nallo2. So it was somewhat more solid, though the technology in the fabric was 20 years old.
It had 3 poles plus a ridge pole if you can be bothered putting it in.
It had 3 guy ropes each side.
So it stands to reason that it should be stronger (so long as the fabric improvements aren't THAT much better).
The Nallo2 is made from light weight (and the key word here is
weight) fabric that is strong - 12 kilo tear strength sounds impressive but what does it actually mean?
It only has two poles. The pegs are somewhat smaller and are very VERY light.
My only concern with the Nallo2 at this stage are the length and therefore strength in the ground, of the pegs.
I can buy after-market pegs, or take the pegs from the Snowcave if I want to. But at this stage, the good Tassie soil has been reliable for the Nallo2 pegs.
Would I hesitate in pitching it anywhere the Snowcave went? No.
Would I have a rough night because of it?
Well, to be honest, even in the Snowcave on a rough night I don't sleep comfortably, and I have a plan prepared in case things get really really bad...
Like, on the Snowcave's last major
exhibition expedition (that's what I meant - that was the wine talking again), Mt Anne Feb 2008, having climbed Mt Anne that day and returning to Shelf Camp, other posts on this forum will show photos of how well the tent was anchored down, and we got a front (which I knew about) come across that night, bringing a reasonable amount of snow (summer, late February). It was a restless nights sleep, and my backup plan was (bearing in mind this is in case of total disaster like tent destruction on the wind or something) -
Get all gear on including Japara and plastic pants
Get readily eatable food in pockets
Water bottle accessable
Head torches on
Compass and whistle around neck
Pack all gear as quickly as possible into the packs
Stay together and plod on through the night toward Eliza Hut
Take rest and shelter behind boulders etc when necessary
Map and GPS accessable in case cairned route cannot be foundAnd so it goes....
But of course it wasn't necessary, the front was nowhere near that bad. Just a bit of wind and snow.
If it was forecast to be cyclonic I don't reckon I would have risked staying there.
I see no reason why I wouldn't do the same in the Hilleberg. Time will tell, surely one of these days I will get some bad weather when I go walking.
Worst I have had was on Moonlight Ridge with a mate in his Chinese copy of a tunnel tent, tent destruction like you wouldn't believe but I live to walk another day.
Would I pitch the Hilleberg on Moonlight Ridge in preparation for that night? NO! But I wouldn't pitch the Snowcave there either.