Vote for and discuss the entries in the regular and ad-hoc photo competitions. Instructions for entering competitions are also here.

Forum rules

Please avoid commenting on individual competition entries before the associated poll has closed, so as to avoid influencing other voters.

TO ENTER THE CURRENT MONTHLY PHOTO COMPETITION, go to the Photo Competition entry page and upload your picture using the entry form there. Each competition is open for entries from the 20th of the month to the 19th of the following month. The rules of each competition are on the same page as the entry form.

The entry form page can also be used to review and/or replace existing entries.

This forum is for competition voting and discussion only - not for submitting entries.

Note that only moderators can create new topics in this forum.
Post a reply

Vote for your favourite photo from the list below from Landscape October 2011

Poll ended at Mon 28 Nov, 2011 9:06 am

1 - Jerusalem Creek, Bundjalung National Park, NSW
2
5%
2 - A Lake St Clair sun rise
1
3%
3 - Third Falls Morialta
0
No votes
4 - Seascape - sunset at The Wrecks, Moreton Island.
11
30%
5 - Mount Teneriffe, Victoria
0
No votes
6 - Bathurst Harbour and beyond
9
24%
7 - View towards Cape Huay
1
3%
8 - National Pass, Blue Mountains, NSW
3
8%
9 - Lockley Pylon approaching sunset
1
3%
10 - A Ned Kellyesque view of things.
1
3%
11 - Elebana Falls, Lamington NP Queensland
3
8%
12 - Seal Creek, Sandpatch Wilderness area, Vic
5
14%
 
Total votes : 37

Landscape October 2011

Mon 21 Nov, 2011 9:06 am

1 - Jerusalem Creek, Bundjalung National Park, NSW
Image


2 - A Lake St Clair sun rise
Image


3 - Third Falls Morialta
Image


4 - Seascape - sunset at The Wrecks, Moreton Island.
Image


5 - Mount Teneriffe, Victoria
Image


6 - Bathurst Harbour and beyond
Image


7 - View towards Cape Huay
Image


8 - National Pass, Blue Mountains, NSW
Image


9 - Lockley Pylon approaching sunset
Image


10 - A Ned Kellyesque view of things.
Image


11 - Elebana Falls, Lamington NP Queensland
Image


12 - Seal Creek, Sandpatch Wilderness area, Vic
Image

(This post/poll automatically generated by the Photo Competition system)

Landscape October 2011 Result

Mon 28 Nov, 2011 10:15 am

Congratulations to the winner of the Landscape October 2011 competition, with 11 votes:

  • Pteropus - Seascape - sunset at The Wrecks, Moreton Island.

The key to all entries for this competition is below.

1 - Jerusalem Creek, Bundjalung National Park, NSW
by phan_TOM.

2 - A Lake St Clair sun rise
by Phil.

3 - Third Falls Morialta
by eggs.

4 - Seascape - sunset at The Wrecks, Moreton Island.
by Pteropus.

5 - Mount Teneriffe, Victoria
by iandsmith.

6 - Bathurst Harbour and beyond
by stepbystep.

7 - View towards Cape Huay
by Stibb.

8 - National Pass, Blue Mountains, NSW
by Vern.

9 - Lockley Pylon approaching sunset
by johnw.

10 - A Ned Kellyesque view of things.
by doogs.

11 - Elebana Falls, Lamington NP Queensland
by Al and Bruce Paton.

12 - Seal Creek, Sandpatch Wilderness area, Vic
by jcr_au.

Re: Landscape October 2011

Tue 06 Dec, 2011 6:37 pm

The winner is clearly a seascape in a landscape competition, scandal !!! ;) Great shot Pteropus a fine winner :)

Landscape October 2011

Tue 06 Dec, 2011 8:16 pm

Do you think we need another category?

Re: Landscape October 2011

Tue 06 Dec, 2011 8:36 pm

That was tongue in cheek wasn't it ? ?
But as was remarked last time - people vote how they vote.

I had thought this was a bit more artistic though - specially with the decorative pieces in it.
But pteropus missed out last time with some fine shots in various categories as well - so fair's fair.

Re: Landscape October 2011

Tue 06 Dec, 2011 8:51 pm

eggs wrote:That was tongue in cheek wasn't it ? ?
But as was remarked last time - people vote how they vote.

I had thought this was a bit more artistic though - specially with the decorative pieces in it.
But pteropus missed out last time with some fine shots in various categories as well - so fair's fair.

Yes, tongue firmly in my cheek! I think it is great to see everybodies interpretations of the new categories as it throws up some very interesting photos. The new comps set up definitely broadens the scope. I don't think we need to add on any more categories :)

Re: Landscape October 2011

Tue 06 Dec, 2011 10:03 pm

doogs wrote:The winner is clearly a seascape in a landscape competition, scandal !!! ;) Great shot Pteropus a fine winner :)


Hahaha thanks doogs, I wondered if the photo was appropriate for "landscape"...but if you look real close, the mainland is on the horizon somewhere across the bay, and I was standing on the land too :wink:
I did actually wonder how it would go with all those man-made decorations though...however, a bit of scrap metal does seem to enhance a pretty sunset!

Re: Landscape October 2011

Tue 06 Dec, 2011 10:10 pm

by the way doogs, I thought your photo of Mt Ossa?? was a very clever idea...which i might just steal when I get down to the Overland Track sometime in the future (in the thievin' spirit of Ned Kelly) :wink:

Re: Landscape October 2011

Wed 07 Dec, 2011 3:47 pm

Hey Pteropus, a very nice shot!
I struggle to get things balanced so nicely at that time of day, particularly retaining the colour/detail you have in the foreground err I mean water. I like the wrecks too but I bet you would have liked that motor boat to move over!

Can't believe I climbed Mt Rugby and couldn't take a winning shot(says about my skills with a camera i think).... :(

Re: Landscape October 2011

Wed 07 Dec, 2011 7:34 pm

stepbystep wrote:Hey Pteropus, a very nice shot!
I struggle to get things balanced so nicely at that time of day, particularly retaining the colour/detail you have in the foreground err I mean water. I like the wrecks too but I bet you would have liked that motor boat to move over!

Can't believe I climbed Mt Rugby and couldn't take a winning shot(says about my skills with a camera i think).... :(


Thanks Stepbystep. I took several shots and though the boat was not in all of them, i think that all the elements were in the right place for this photo. I often have a problem with getting the horizon level...and I dont have fancy processing software to fix it, just the basic Canon software that came with the camera. Most of my other shots of the Wrecks had sloping horizons so this one made the cut....
Sbs, your shot over Bathurst Harbour is great. 9 votes says you took a great shot. However, I did vote for my own in this “landscape” comp and in the “Other states” comp too, but not in the “non-landscape” comp this time as i liked another’s photo better. I wonder how many vote for their own photos?

Re: Landscape October 2011

Thu 08 Dec, 2011 1:33 pm

Pteropus wrote:...Most of my other shots of the Wrecks had sloping horizons so this one made the cut....

Hi Pteropus, This one of my pet hates but I can often fix it by doing a simple rotate and crop. Basic software that comes with operating systems (eg WIndows Picture Manager), or camera software will often do it.

Congratulations on an excellent photo by the way :). I forecast it being a likely winner as soon as I saw it. The competitions are attracting some really nice shots. Great work everyone :).

stepbystep wrote:Can't believe I climbed Mt Rugby and couldn't take a winning shot

Nothing wrong with your Mt Rugby shot Dan. Maybe we need another category for most challenging photo to acquire :wink:.

Re: Landscape October 2011

Fri 09 Dec, 2011 9:32 am

johnw wrote:
Pteropus wrote:...Most of my other shots of the Wrecks had sloping horizons so this one made the cut....

Hi Pteropus, This one of my pet hates but I can often fix it by doing a simple rotate and crop. Basic software that comes with operating systems (eg WIndows Picture Manager), or camera software will often do it.


Hey John, thanks, I had no idea that Windows Picture Manager could do that until you said so! I had thought it only rotated it 90° at a time, or flipped it. The Canon software I use is a little dated and does not allow slight adjustments in alignment. Sometime down the track I might even get Light Room or Photoshop...

I mentioned my issue of non-straight horizons with a friend who is a professional photographer, and she said the mirror might be slightly out of alignment with the sensor. Consequently, no matter how long one spends trying to get the horizon perfect, it might always be on an angle...but I am not really one to blame my tools though :wink:

Re: Landscape October 2011

Fri 09 Dec, 2011 10:59 am

If you don't want Photoshop elements ($100 in Aus, $49.95 in US Grrr) there is an opensource (free) alternative called Gimp that you could try

Re: Landscape October 2011

Fri 09 Dec, 2011 12:45 pm

jcr_au wrote:If you don't want Photoshop elements ($100 in Aus, $49.95 in US Grrr) there is an opensource (free) alternative called Gimp that you could try

Yes, I also have The Gimp. Well worth downloading. A bit of a steep learning curve to get the most out of it, but not too difficult to use if you take the time to play around with it (I'm still trying to decipher a lot of the functionality). For a freebie it's an absolute gem :).

Re: Landscape October 2011

Fri 09 Dec, 2011 3:24 pm

johnw wrote:Yes, I also have The Gimp. Well worth downloading. A bit of a steep learning curve to get the most out of it, but not too difficult to use if you take the time to play around with it (I'm still trying to decipher a lot of the functionality). For a freebie it's an absolute gem :).


As is Hugin if you want to do stitch panoramas.
Post a reply