Identifying distant peaks

[icefest]

I need some help.

The panorama thread made me revisit some older photos and i'm stuck trying to identify a couple of distant hills (A, B)
I'm standing on the peak of the Irounbounds and looking through the Portal of the Arthurs.

I'm thinking this might be The Thumbs but I can't get the topo to fit. Any ideas?

[Scottyk]

I think The Thumbs is peak B.
I reckon the lower peak A is just the Saw Back Range.
Sort of lines up on my big topo hanging on the lounge room wall.

[frenchy_84]

A would be clear hill and thumbs would be b

[frenchy_84]

Or maybe stepped hills. I usually draw a line in google earth to see if they line up

[icefest]

I tried the google earth trick, It looks like Mt Wright and the thumbs:

[pazzar]

I think Frenchy's first guess is correct. Could not be Stepped Hills or Wright as they would be obscured by the Thumbs. Clear Hill makes sense as it lies about 2km west of the Thumbs.

[tibboh]

Definately The Thumbs for the obvious peak..........but I have my doubts about Clear Hill for a couple of reasons. Clear Hill is pretty much the same height as Thumbs yet appears lower in the photo even thought their distance from the photographer is virtually identical. Secondly The Thumbs appear darker indicating closer????
So my guess for peak A is a more distant part of the Denison Ra? Similar or greater height but further away.....your thoughts?

[stepbystep]

Definitely Clear Hill left, Thumbs right.

[tibboh]

So I had a look with LISTmap and with a strait edge Clear Hill is a fair way to the left of a line from The Ironbound Ra over the Crags to The Thumbs. The deviation is too great from a point we all agree on. You're going to have work harder to convince me it's Clear Hil taking into account my previous post also.

[stepbystep]

So I had a look with LISTmap and with a strait edge Clear Hill is a fair way to the left of a line from The Ironbound Ra over the Crags to The Thumbs. The deviation is too great from a point we all agree on. You're going to have work harder to convince me it's Clear Hil taking into account my previous post also.

Nah. I'm confident

EDIT: Actually no I'm not

[stepbystep]

I think it's Stepped Hills. This is taken from near Lake Prom

Attachments

[stepbystep]

Wrong again. It's Mt Wright!!

[stepbystep]

Profile matches perfectly(I think...)

Attachments

[north-north-west]

I, too, vacillated.

B is definitely Thumbs. First thought was that A had to be Clear Hill, but it's too close given the angle. . .
. . . Wright does make more sense.

[tibboh]

Yeah peak A profile is fairly even with the slope on either side whereas Clear Hill is steeper on the west. Also Wright is close to the right line in the photo, just to the left of Thumbs, and further away and lower in altitude. It ticks all the boxes. Wright is right I think SBS.

[icefest]

Thanks everyone for helping.

[slparker]

You could try the navigation technique of intervisibility to prove what the peaks are (or, rather, prove what peaks are visible on that bearing from that co-ordinate). last time I did this was in a classroom in 1992 and I have never had to do it in real time but from memory, it's a process of trigometrically calculating the elevations that will will be visible in a line of sight.