by Biggles » Fri 14 Jan, 2011 8:53 am
From people I've spoken with it doesn't seem any tent can be considered "overkill" for the Port Davey / South Coast tracks, both of which are subject to the extremes of weather, like that which has lashed, drenched then persistently flooded Victoria (here in Highton Geelong we are on flood watch and the river is 3km away!). Friends have taken an old MacPac Minaret on their 10 day walk along the South Coast and report it held up well but got "filthy, smelly and persistently wet from rain". I'd like to do the South Coast track but only have a Mont Moondance 1 which has proved good at keeping me quite dry sans-heavy rain, but not so dry when heavy rain is blown under the rather airy skirt — got very wet inside during an especially energetic and wet thunderstorm at Wilsons Promontory last November!
A tent that can stand alone on the odd warm night, leaving you in a mozzie-proof coccoon is useful (one of the guiding features of the aforementioned Moondance), but I'd still hedge my bets on getting wet and dirty, often and a lot. Given my future interest in the SC/PD tracks I'll follow other respondents' experiences with interest.
Conversation about the weather is the last refuge of the unimaginative.
—Oscar Wilde, 1890.