Tortoise wrote:Wondering what you think of the maps having checked them out. Any comments?
I think that Garmin's Oz Topo is atrocious for SE Australia, after giving it a bit of a test run.
Where do I start?
For the Northern Australian Alps in particular, insignificant hills are labeled while the most significant mountains aren't even named. When I change the setting from minimum detail to most detail, or maximum rendering to minimum rendering nothing changes within the non-existent important details on the topos.
The childish symbols are pathetic. The symbol for a mountain's summit is not only irritating and can't be removed (?) but is also placed willy-nilly. Big mountains like Bimberi, Morgan, Murray and Franklin and even Tennent aren't labeled or have a childish symbol, while insignificant hills like, Rose, Snowgum, Deadmans and Poppet are well identified and given the status of dominant peaks.
No structures (eg huts, mill, tanks or bores) are indicated but every disused and overgrown quarry in the region is brightly blazed. Nor are property names included or forest types identified. A sterile pine plantation has the same status as a prime forest.
Nothing changes when I change the
Activity Profile, from one activity to another. There are a lot of activity profiles. For example the
Activity Profile for 'walking' is exactly the same for driving and diving.
Walking or
Hiking doesn't show walking tracks, like the Australian Alps Walking Track, but shows a couple of unconnected sections of the Hume and Hovell walking Track. The Bicentennial National Trail, the odd section should be included somewhere possibly in Horse Riding?
West of the ACT Border, not one mountain is labeled in the Bogong Wilderness, the Gooberagandra or Bobbys Plains Wilderness or on the SW Slopes of New South Wales. In fact no mountains are labeled well past Wagga Wagga in the Riverena.
In Kosciuszko National Park only a handful of summits (6) are identified and the Strumbo Range and the Grey Mare Range are there. But if the Geehi River rises another 10 metres, the Grey Mare Range will disappear. Mount Jagungal is incognito as usual, due possibly to low cloud.
Some of the passes are dodgy on the western ACT border with Kosciuszko but most traditional passes are missing (at first glance).
In the Bramina Wilderness, some of the mountain ranges are incorrectly labeled or labeled once at the furthest end of a range and again no mountains are identified ... but I guess, why label a mountain or a mountain range when you can label and name dozens-upon-dozens of disused and overgrown quarries? Someone at Garmin obviously has a quarry fetish (this is not a joke). What is it about quarries that's obviously going over my head?
Also the key that indicates the features on paper topos has not been included, because there are no details to identify anyway. This is certainly not a map set that is an accurate stand alone navigational aid for sophisticated hand held GPS units (unless basic GPS road maps are your thing of course and you're into quarries) ... it will certainly pay to take a real map with you in the back country.
I'm so glad that I didn't pay for this Garmin topo. Being a freebie was good because it is very ordinary map set, indeed. For cycle touring and Mountain Biking on back country roads and along unnamed fire trails (which should all be named, they all have names on real maps) it looks adequate ... and the reason why I'll stick with it until it becomes too frustrating to use ... which could be any day now!
I don't think that I'll transfer my paper topos in the wilder regions of the Alps and Great Divide to the GPS, having the big picture with details is important.
True-blue Aussies call every second Aussie we meet,
MATE. Well
MATES, Garmin has copied our lazy vocabulary and calls every second fire trail in this neck of the bush,
PATH .
I hope your region/s fared better.
Warren.