Hi all,
I didn't use the loaf of bread (Tarptent Notch TI) much on the Bibbulmun to have an opinion but I have just had a 5 day trip in Tassie.
Some random thoughts:-
Was fairly easy to pitch. I felt like I needed to put a rock on each of my Hilleberg tent pegs to get the tent tight enough for wind flapping or snow. Took a couple of goes to get the pitching system down and a bit or re-adjustment but I reckon with a bit more experience will have it up in a few minutes.
I have added 2 long guys so I use 6 pegs in total and it feels really solid (especially with the rocks).
Had rain one night and I had to get out while fly still wet - was able to roll it back without water flicking or dripping in the tent.
Camped by lakes all 4 nights so had plenty of condensation but never even looked like being a problem. I was able to sit up OK and feet and head were close to the sides and ends but never had an issue with the condensation.
Not heaps of room inside but I found with a dry bag at my head and feet plus the bit of room each side it was ample. My Aarn Natural Balance fitted fine in one vestibule and boots etc in the other.
I liked how you just pitch it and then work out which way to sleep as 2 doors at opposite ends meant less planning.
The worst thing is the way the vestibule joins together. It has a metal clip and one side clips under the other but you have to reach right out and hold both sides to fasten or exit which is a bit of a pain but the velcro seems to work well keeping it together.
The magnets worked fine when rolling back the fly as did the elastic on the inner doors.
I bought the Tyvek groundsheet from TarpTent cut to size. Not sure if it is necessary but thought I would start with it and see but I have never used a groundsheet before on Hillebergs. The Tyvek is so noisy. Have just put it in the washing machine 3 times and it seems a bit better. First night the groundsheet walked about 30 cm (one foot) out from under the tent so I put the walking poles (tent poles) just on each side which helped the remaining nights. I found it easier to pitch the tent and then slip the groundsheet under in the wind.
Would be a small space if tent-bound but overall I am really pleased with my purchase. I had a look at the StratoSphire TI for a bigger space for when my wife comes and it looks good too although I reckon this Notch will handle severe winds or snow marginally better.
Anyway, if there is no Snow forecast I will be taking the Notch TI in future but I reckon it will go OK with some snow.
Some photos:-
https://www.facebook.com/andrew.richman.58Cheers,
Andrew