by etrangere » Fri 24 Dec, 2010 6:32 pm
I have both the StS shower and the MSR Dromedary bag shower kit.
The StS one works fine, it has a 10L capacity but found I was able to have a quick shower using only 2 to 3 liters. The downside is that with you dont get much water pressure with a smaller volume of water. As the volume decreases you can grab the bag and giving it a squeeze to get the last drops out under some half decent pressure. I ended up filling it up with 10 liters, taking a quick shower (2 - 3L) and pouring the unused water back into my jerry can (4WD trip), a bit fiddly to do. I found that even when turned off it still leaks a bit, not sure if thats a common thing or just a fault mine had perhaps. Slightly annoying when trying to dry yourself/put on clothes while standing on a small bit of plastic to keep feet clean!
I already had 6L and 10L MSR dromedary bags and spotted the "MSR shower kit" on sale so thought what the heck and bought it. The hose on it is pretty long which means you have to hang the bag quite high to have the nozzle at head height plus also the shower ends up spraying everywhere if you dont grab the nozzle end and direct the spray. I ended up cutting the hose to only about 10cm in length, makes it much more user friendly and easier to pack.
MSR
advantages - sealed bag, easy to fill, watertight tap, easy to turn on and off, tap doesn't leak
cons - you may end up using valuable filtered/drinking water unless you carry an extra dromedary bag for showering, slighly awkward shape for packing, you need to purchase or already have a MSR dromedary bag
StS
advantages - separate bag from drinking water container, packs up neatly in own bag which then has a more uniformed shape to fit into a mug or pack more easily in backpack
cons - slight leak even after turned off, awkward to fill and roll end to seal compared to MSR kit
And make sure you pack either thongs or a small tarp/plastic sheet to stand on otherwise you just end up with a clean body but with dust/dirt clinging all over your feet