by sthughes » Fri 09 Mar, 2012 2:47 pm
I had the opportunity to carry a friends One Planet Shadow 56L (old model but same harness as new) a few weeks back. I was mighty impressed with it! Honestly it was the most comfortable thing I have ever carried, better than my McMillan, and I thought that was excellent.
But then because they are over $300 and the new ones are thin canvas (probably still tough enough) I ended up buying a Lowe Alpine Zepton 50 XL (Dyneema pack) cheap from Sierra Trading Post. It is yet to arrive - so stay tuned. I may yet sell it and lash out on a Shadow! Also looked at the Osprey Exos series, but quite thin fabric and sooo many buckles, bands, straps etc. to rip off. Still it was very tempting as I like the harness setup on them. Of course only the Shadow is truly adjustable, the others will either fit or not, and are lighter partly because of it.
I think those three all meet the specs, not sure on the Shadow for hydration though. It does have great bottle holders though which mean a bottle hydration system could be used instead of a bladder.
"Don't do today what you can put off 'till tomorrow." (Work that is!)