by Ent » Wed 14 Dec, 2011 9:31 pm
Hi
I have tried quite a few pairs and the winner to-date is the One Planet ones. Sea to Summit generally fail because they use a hard material and soft so the flexing does in the stitching and/or the softer material. Wilderness Equipment are a great boot covering design but the S type fitting for the shock cord are a disaster as very little stitching holding them together. They do make a slightly different approach with a nylon tab (as they originally did) and that is better. Found with them dumping the shock cord for MacPac wire straps worthwhile but go for the small wire straps. Heck, I wear size 49 boots and even the small wire under-strap is a bit on the big size.
For comfort OP get the nod as well. Thing to be aware off is they are designed to sit higher on the boot. Apparently, the reason for that is most boots nowadays have the tongue sealed where in the older boots the tongue was not sealed so the older gaiters were designed to seal lower on the boot. Found that the OP work well in keeping water out in a quick creek splash.
I much prefer canvas over other materials. Friend found nylon ones way too sweaty.
Cheers
"lt only took six years. From now on, l´ll write two letters a week instead of one."
(Shawshank Redemption)